.
By Ed Gerritsen, February 2014
Collection Overview
Abstract
The collections contains Alvin Plantinga's notes and papers (1950-1955) while a student, and correspondence (1956-2010) that spans his teaching and writing careers on such topics as God, freedom, evil, creation and evolution. His writings (1961-2010) details his arguments relating to God whose existence does not present a logical inconsistency with the existence of evil, free will for humans, and that a creation with moral good necessitates the existence of moral evil. The collections also details his argument that if evolution is true, it undermines naturalism because if both evolution and naturalism are true, human cognitive faculties must evolve directed toward survival rather than truth, and these faculties would be unreliable in discerning truth. On the other hand, if God created man "in his image" by way of an evolutionary process (or any other means), then Plantinga argues our faculties would probably be reliable.
Biographical Note
At the end of 11th grade, Plantinga's father urged Plantinga to skip his last year of high school and enroll in college and in 1949, a few months before his 17th birthday, he enrolled in Jamestown College, in Jamestown, North Dakota. When his father joined the faculty at Calvin College in January 1950, the younger Plantinga enrolled in Calvin College. During his first semester at Calvin, Plantinga was awarded a scholarship to attend Harvard University, where her spent two semesters but returned to Calvin in 1951 to study philosophy with William Harry Jellema In 1954. Plantinga began his graduate studies at the University of Michigan with William Alston, William Frankena, and Richard Cartwright, and in 1955 transferred to Yale University where he received his PhD in 1958.
Plantinga taught philosophy at Yale, 1957-1958; Wayne State University, 1958-1963; Calvin College (replacing the retiring Jellema), 1963-1982; and the University of Notre Dame, 1982-2010. He has honorary degrees from Glasgow University (1982), North Park College (1994), the Free University of Amsterdam (1995), Brigham Young University (1996), and Valparaiso University (1999). He was a Guggenheim Fellow, 1971-1972, and elected a Fellow in the American Academy of Arts and Sciences in 1975. In 2006 the University of Notre Dame's Center for Philosophy of Religion renamed its Distinguished Scholar Fellowship as the Alvin Plantinga Fellowship. In 2012, the University of Pittsburgh's Philosophy Department, History and Philosophy of Science Department, and the Center for the History and Philosophy of Science awarded Plantinga the Rescher Prize.
Plantinga was born on 15 November 1932, in Ann Arbor, Michigan to Cornelius A. Plantinga (1908-1994) and Lettie G. Bossenbroek (1908-2007). Plantinga's father, an immigrant from Friesland, the Netherlands, earned Master's Degree in psychology and a PhD in philosophy from Duke University. Alvin Plantinga married Kathleen De Boer in 1955 and they have four children: Carl, Jane, Harry, and Ann. Both sons are professors at Calvin College, Carl in Film Studies and Harry in computer science; daughter, Jane Plantinga Pauw, is a pastor at Rainier Beach Presbyterian Church (PCUSA) in Seattle, Washington, and his daughter, Ann Kapteyn, is a missionary in Cameroon working for Wycliffe Bible Translators.
Administrative Information
Repository:
Heritage Hall, Hekman Library
Alternate Extent Statement:
30 Boxes
Acquisition Source:
Alvin Plantinga, 2012, 2013
Other Note:
Acc. No. 12.66, 13.15
Box and Folder Listing
Browse by Series:
[
Series 1: [General Materials]],
[
Series 2: Correspondence, 1950-2010],
[
Series 3: Writings, 1963-2008, undated],
[
Series 4: Articles],
[
Series 5: Research Material],
[
Series 6: Research Material; A Theory of Content and Other Essays, by Jerry Fodor, 1990, 1972-1981, undated],
[All]
- Series 1: [General Materials]
- Box 1
- Folder 1: Curriculum Vitae
- Folder 2: Paper: "Elements of Pre-Socratic Thought in "Phaedo" and the "Times" --- 1951
- Folder 3: Paper: "Carlyle and the Problem of Faith" --- 1950's
- Folder 4: Paper: "A.E. Taylor: Does God Exist?" --- 1950's
- Folder 5: Class Notes on Ethics Courses --- 1950's
- Folder 6-7: Papers Written for Class Assignments --- 1950-1954
- Folder 8: Class Notes on Contemporary Psychology --- 1952
- Folder 9: Class Notes on History of Psychology --- 1952-1953
- Folder 10: Class Notes on Theory of Learning --- 1950-1952
- Folder 11: Class Notes on 19th Century Prose --- 1952
- Folder 12: Class Notes on Advanced General Psychology --- 1952
- Folder 13: Paper: "Whitehead's Concept of Causality" --- 1954
- Folder 14: Papers:
- Item 1: “The metaphysics of Spinoza”
- Item 2: “Taylor’s Theistic Arguments” --- 1955
- Folder 15: Class notes for Ф of Religion Course at University of Michigan --- 1955
- Folder 16: Paper: "Explanation of Ethics" --- 1955
- Folder 17: Lecture Notes on Plato-Harvard College --- 1951
- Series 2: Correspondence --- 1950-2010
- Box 2
- Folder 1: 1950-1959
- Folder 2-11: 1960-1969
- Box 3
- Folder 1-3: 1970-1971
- Folder 4: Publication of the "The Nature of Necessity" --- 1971-1973
- Folder 5-6: 1972
- Folder 7: With Tyler --- 1972-1975
- Box 4
- Folder 1-6: 1973-1975
- Box 5
- Folder 1-5: 1976-1977
- Folder 6: Publication of "God, Freedom and Evil" --- 1977
- Folder 7-8: 1978-1979
- Box 6
- Folder 1-6: 1980-1982
- Box 7
- Folder 1-6: 1983-1985
- Box 8
- Folder 1-4: 1986
- Box 9
- Folder 1-3: 1987
- Folder 4: re: Creation/ Evolution --- 1988-1993
- Folder 5: Jan-Apr, 1988
- Box 10
- Folder 1-3: May-Dec, 1988
- Folder 4: With Patrick Grimm --- 1988-1991
- Folder 5-6: Jan-May, 1989
- Box 11
- Folder 1-5: Jun 1989-1990
- Box 12
- Folder 1-4: 1991
- Box 13
- Folder 1-5: 1992
- Box 14
- Folder 1-6: 1993
- Folder 7: With H. Vantill and J. Stek, re: Evolution etc. --- 1993-1994
- Box 15
- Folder 1-5: 1994-Mar 1995
- Box 16
- Folder 1-4: Apr 1995-1996
- Box 17
- Folder 1-5: 1997-1998
- Box 18
- Folder 1-8: 1999-2002
- Box 19
- Folder 1-4: 2003-2006
- Folder 5: Publication Rights --- 2005-2007
- Folder 6-9: 2007-2010
- Series 3: Writings --- 1963-2008, undated
- Box 20
- Folder 1: "Plantinga on the Free Will Defense" (Clement Dore) --- 1971
- Folder 2-3: "Aquinas and Calvin on Faith and Knowledge" --- 1980
- Folder 4: "Reason and Scripture Scholarship" --- 1986
- Folder 5: "Comments on Plantinga" (R. Feldman) and Reply by A.C.P. --- 1986
- Folder 6: "A Modest Professor" (Interview of A.C.P.) --- 1989
- Folder 7: "The Necessity of Proper Function" --- 1992
- Folder 8-9: "Reid, Hume, and God" --- 1995
- Folder 10: Papers Given at Plantinga Symposium --- Jun 1995
- Folder 11: "Darwin, Mind, and Meaning" --- 1996
- Folder 12: "On Christian Scholarship" --- 1996
- Folder 13: "On Being Honest to God" --- nd
- Folder 14: "Do We Have a Right to Fight for Opec Oil?" --- nd
- Folder 15: "On Actuality" --- nd
- Folder 16: "The Paradox of the Heap" --- nd
- Folder 17: "Do our Concepts Apply to God?" --- nd
- Folder 18: "Precis of Christian Philosophy at End of 20th Century" --- nd
- Folder 19: "Plantinga's Account of Epistemic Warrant" --- nd
- Folder 20: "What's the Question?" --- nd
- Folder 21: "Bonjourian Coherentism" --- nd
- Folder 22: "Naturalism Defeated" --- nd
- Folder 23: "Warrant and Designing Agents: A Reply to James Taylor" --- nd
- Folder 24: "Reply to Sosa and Goldman" --- nd
- Folder 25: "Perceiving God" --- nd
- Box 21
- Folder 1: "Presuppositions of Our Time" --- undated
- Folder 2: "Actuality, Truth, and Trust-in" --- nd
- Folder 3: "Methodological Naturalism?" --- undated
- Folder 4: "On Being Evidentially Challenged" --- nd
- Folder 5: "Epistemic Probability, and Evil" --- nd
- Folder 6: "An Evolutionary Argument against Naturalism" --- nd
- Folder 7: "Divine Knowledge" --- nd
- Folder 8: "On Mereological Essentialism," (R.M. Chisholm), A.C.P. Response --- nd
- Folder 9: "Existence, Self-Interest, and the Problem of Evil," (R.M.), Reply by A.C.P --- nd
- Folder 10: "Reflections on a Methodology for Christian Philosophers," (J. Keller), and Replies --- nd
- Folder 11: "Falsification and the Existence of God: A Discussion of Plantinga's Freewill Defense," (G. Rotterwill) --- nd
- Folder 12: "Plantinga's Freewill Defense," (W. Hasker) --- nd
- Folder 13: "Plantinga and Leibniz's Lapse," (R. Burch) --- nd
- Folder 14: "Plantinga on Probability and Evil," (R. Swinburne) --- nd
- Folder 15: "God, Plantinga and a Better World" --- nd
- Folder 16: "Alvin Plantinga and the Great Pumpkin" --- nd
- Folder 17: "Plantinga's Modal Freewill Defense" --- nd
- Folder 18: "Can, There is a God be a Basic Belief?" (M. Stewart) --- nd
- Folder 19: "Afterword" --- nd
- Folder 20: "Plantinga on Functions and the Theory of Evolution" (M. Levin) --- nd
- Folder 21: "Transworld Identity-The Unstated Premise of Plantinga's Reformulation of Ontological Argument," (P.M. O'Neil) --- nd
- Folder 22: "Christian Theism: Ultimate Reality and Meaning in the Philosophy of Alvin Plantinga," (D, Giutebga) --- nd
- Folder 23: "Taking Plantinga Seriously: More Advise to Christian Philosophers," (M. Westphall) --- nd
- Folder 24: "Reid, Hume, and God" --- nd
- Folder 25: "The Evidentialist Objection to Theistic Belief" --- nd
- Box 22
- Folder 1: Christianity Today article: "Analytic Philosophy and Christianity" --- 1963
- Folder 2: Reformed Journal article: "Radical Theology" --- 1967
- Folder 3: Reformed Journal article: "Why Climb Mountains?" --- 1969
- Folder 4: Article: "Plantinga's Theology of Proper Names," (D.F. Austin- Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic) --- 1983
- Folder 5: Article: "The Boethian Compromise" and Reply by Diana Akerman --- 1978
- Folder 6: Article: "The Probabilistic Argument from Evil" --- 1978
- Folder 7: Pro Rege Article: "Modernizing the Case for God," (N. Van Til- response by A.C.P.) --- 1981
- Folder 8: Reformed Journal Article: "Sheehan's Shenanigans" --- 1987
- Series 4: Articles
- Box 22
- Folder 9: "Two Concepts of Modality: Modal Realism and Modal Reductionism" --- 1987
- Folder 10: "Justification and Theism," (Faith and Philosophy) --- 1987
- Folder 11: "Positive Epistemic Status and Proper Function" --- 1988
- Folder 12: "The Prospects for Natural Theology" --- 1991
- Folder 13: "Truth, Omniscience, and Cantorian Arguments: An Exchange," (By Plantinga and Grim) --- 1992
- Folder 14: "Dennett's Dangerous Idea," (Books and Culture) --- 1996
- Folder 15: "Twenty Years Worth of SCP," (Faith and Philosophy) --- 1998
- Folder 16: "On Proper Basicality" --- 2007
- Folder 17: "What is Intervention?," (Theology and Science) --- 2008
- Folder 18: "Divine Knowledge" --- nd
- Folder 19: "Rejecting the Theory of Common Ancestry" --- nd
- Folder 20: "Truth, Omniscience, and Cantorian Arguments," (Plantinga and Grim) --- nd
- Folder 21: Natural Theology: "The Esistemology of Religious Belief" --- nd
- Folder 22: "Reason and Belief in God" --- nd
- Folder 23: "Christian, Scholars, and Christian Scholars" --- nd
- Folder 24: "Justification in the 20th Century" --- nd
- Folder 25: Notes and Outlines for Oxford Lectures --- nd
- Folder 26: Outlines for Glasgow Lectures --- nd
- Folder 27: Lecture: "The Reformed Objection to Natural Theology" --- 1980
- Folder 28: Address: "How to be an Anti-Realist" --- 1982
- Folder 29: Final Draft for "Coherentism and the Evidentialist Objection to Belief in God" --- nd
- Box 23
- Folder 1: Syllabus for Gifford Lectures --- 1987
- Folder 2: Stob Lectures: "Reformed Thinking: Christian Scholarship" and "Christian Thinking: The Twin Pillars"; The Twin Pillars of Christian Scholarship, --- 1989
- Folder 3: A.C.P. Comments on Malcom's Paper-Oxford Philosophical Society --- Jan 1976
- Folder 4: Draft of "God and Laws of Logic"
- Folder 5: Notes and Drafts of Papers on Natural Theology --- nd
- Folder 6: Review of "Faith and Rationality: Reason and Belief in God," (M.P. Levine) --- nd
- Folder 7: Review of "Language, Persons, and Belief," (Commonweal Magazine) --- 1968
- Folder 8: Review of "Plantinga: A Profile" --- nd
- Folder 9: Review of "Science and Religion: Why Does the Debate Continued?" --- nd
- Folder 10: Critique of Alvin Goldman
- Folder 11: Review of "Warrant and Proper Function" --- 1993
- Folder 12: Review of "God, Freedom, and Evil," (Reviewed by G. Allen) --- 1975
- Folder 13: Review of "Faith and Rationality," (Reviewed by J.E. Tomberlin) --- 1986
- Folder 14: Review of "The First Coming: How the Kingdom of God Became Christianity," (T. Sheean) --- nd
- Folder 15: Book Reviews of "God and Other Minds" --- nd
- Folder 16: Review of "How the Kingdom of God Became Christianity," (Review by A.C.P.) --- nd
- Folder 17: A Critical Survey of Plantinga's "Warranted Christian Belief" --- nd
- Folder 18: Critique of the Nature of Necessity and Related Material, (R.L. Purtill) --- nd
- Folder 19: Critique on Plantinga's View on the Rationality of Belief in God," (A. Kenny) --- nd
- Folder 20: Critique on Draper --- nd
- Folder 21: Talk on Aquinas --- nd
- Folder 22: Chapel Talks --- nd
- Box 24
- Folder 1: Summer Institute for College Teachers in Philosophy of Religion, Calvin College --- 1973
- Folder 2: National Endowment for the Humanities (NEH) Summer Seminar --- 1975
- Folder 3: Summer Seminar in Philosophy and Religion, Calvin College --- 1978
- Folder 4: Notes of Notre Dame Seminar on the Philosophy of Religion --- 1982
- Folder 5: American Philosophical Association Officer Nominations --- 1983
- Folder 6: Workshop on Christianity and Philosophy, Westmount College --- 1984
- Folder 7: Summer Institute in Philosophy of Religion, W. Washington University --- 1985
- Folder 8: 25th Philosophical Reunion, Pamplona, Spain --- 1987
- Box 25
- Folder 1: Dialogue with William Carter
- Folder 2: Reply to Sessions and Vanhook --- 1985
- Folder 3: Reply to Levine, Steuer, and Robbins --- nd
- Folder 4: Reply to Gary Gutting --- nd
- Folder 5: Response to William Vallicella --- nd
- Folder 6: Comments on Clouser's Claims --- nd
- Folder 7: Application for Sabbatical Leave --- nd
- Folder 8: Council for Philosophical Studies Material --- 1972
- Folder 9: E. Harris Harbison Award for Distinguished Teaching --- 1968
- Folder 10: Material Endowment for the Humanities Fellowship --- 1975-1967
- Folder 11: Philosophy 331 Course, Wolterstorff on Kant --- 1975
- Folder 12: Thesis: "A Study of Plantinga's View about Validity of Religious Belief". (M.A. Mobini) --- nd
- Folder 13: Tribute to "KK" (Ken Konyndyk) --- nd
- Folder 14: Material re: Rock Climbing
- Folder 15: Interview of A.P. --- nd
- Folder 16: Interview with Professor A. Plantinga, (Krisis-University of Timiboara) --- nd
- Folder 17: Interview with Professor A.C. Plantinga, (A. Varghese) --- 1993
- Folder 18: "Parting Reflections," (On Leaving Calvin College for Notre Dame) --- nd
- Series 5: Research Material
- Box 26
- Folder 1: "Coherentism and the Problem of the Criterion," (M.R. DePaul) --- nd
- Folder 2: "Tarski's Theory of Truth" --- nd
- Folder 3: "Kant's Objection to the Ontological Argument" --- nd
- Folder 4: Papers by W. Palston --- nd
- Folder 5: "Essays on the Philosophy of R.H. Chisholm," (E. Sosa) --- nd
- Folder 6: Papers by Clement Dore
- Folder 7: "What is the Theory of Meaning?," (M.A.E. Dummett) --- nd
- Folder 8: Papers by K.S. Donnellan
- Folder 9: "A Coherence of Truth and Knowledge," (D. Davidson) --- nd
- Folder 10: Review of "Does God have a Nature?" --- nd
- Folder 11: Interview of Dr. W.R. Jellema by Dr. Dirk Jellema and Herb. Brinks --- nd
- Folder 12: Draft of Paper "Omniscience-Immutability Arguments," (R.M. Gale) --- nd
- Folder 13: "Christianity and the Class Struggle," (Abraham Kuyper) --- nd
- Folder 14: "New Wrinkles on Old Fatalisms" (A. Falk) --- nd
- Folder 15: "Can Philosophical Beliefs be Rationally Justified?," (G. Gutting) --- nd
- Folder 16: "Concerning the Intelligibility of "God is Timeless"," (W. Hasker) --- nd
- Folder 17: "Models and Reality," (H. Putnam) --- 1980
- Box 27
- Folder 1: "The Philosophical Significance of One Way Speed of Light," (W.C. Salmon) --- nd
- Folder 2: "Recent Work on the Mind-Body Problem" and "Mental Events, Bodies, and Persons" (J.A. Shaffer) --- nd
- Folder 3: "Classical Analysis," (E. Sosa) --- nd
- Folder 4: Mereological Essentialism --- nd
- Series 6: Research Material; A Theory of Content and Other Essays, by Jerry Fodor, 1990 --- 1972-1981, undated
- Chapters 2 and 3 have marginalia from Plantinga.
- Box 27
- Folder 5: "Rationality and Religious Belief" --- 1977
- Folder 6: "The Sense of the Heart," (W. Edwards) --- nd
- Folder 7: Frisian Thought
- Folder 8: "Logic, Meaning, and Conceptual Role," Journal of Philosophy --- 1977
- Folder 9: The Concept of Evil
- Folder 10: "Could God Have Created us in an Idyllic World?," (R.M. Adams) --- nd
- Folder 11: "The Probabilistic Problem of Evil," (R. Otte) --- nd
- Folder 12: "The Intrinsic Value in Disjunctive States of Affairs" (R.M. Chisholm) --- nd
- Folder 13: "Introductory Notes on the Theory of Truth," (Tyler Burge) --- 1972
- Folder 14: "Carnapis Inductive Logic," (W.C. Salmon) --- nd
- Folder 15: "A Good God," (Ulf Gorman) --- nd
- Box 28
- Folder 1: "Comments on Alston's "Religious Experience and Religious Belief"," (P. Vaninwagen) --- nd
- Folder 2: "The Meaning of a Proper Name," (J. L. Pollock) --- nd
- Folder 3: "The Resurrection Hope," (H.S. Strandness) --- nd
- Folder 4: "The Problem of Other Minds," (S. Shoemaker) --- nd
- Folder 5: "Possible Worlds" and "Propositional Modalities," (J.L. Pollock) --- nd
- Folder 6: "A Problem about the Dynamics of Belief" (J. Perry) --- nd
- Folder 7: "Explaining the Paradoxes: The Cantorian Way Out," (C. Menzel) --- nd
- Folder 8: "Paradoxes, Large Sets, and Proper Classes," (C. Menzel) --- nd
- Folder 9: "Could God have Created a Perfect World?," (P. Mellema) --- nd
- Folder 10: "A New Actualist Model Semantics," and "A problem for Actualism on Possible Worlds," (A. McMichael) --- nd
- Folder 11: "Reflections on Christian Philosophy," (R. McInerny) --- nd
- Folder 12: Chapters of Book on the Divine, (R.M. Adams) --- nd
- Folder 13: Article: "Leibnz on Possible Worlds" (B. Mates), Paper: "Individuals and Modality in the Philosophy of Leibnz" --- nd
- Folder 14: "Bar-on Spinoza's Ontological Proof," (R.B. Marcus) --- nd
- Folder 15: "A Proposed Solution to a Puzzle about Belief," (Marcus on Kripke) --- nd
- Folder 16: "Space, Yes; Time, No," (Frederick Manfred) --- 1981
- Folder 17: "The Virtue of Faith" and "Involuntary Sins," (R.M. Adams) --- nd
- Folder 18: "Possible Worlds" and "Plantinga on Possible Worlds," (J.L. Pollock), reply by A.C.P. --- nd
- Box 29
- Folder 1: "Ratzsch on Kuyper" --- nd
- Folder 2: "Fates and Faces of Epistemology," (E. Sosa) --- nd
- Folder 3: "A Puzzle about Belief," (S.A. Kripke) --- nd
- Folder 4: "Proper Names and Direct Reference on Proper Names in Belief and Ascriptions," (T. McKay) --- nd
- Folder 5: "Divine Simplicity," (W.E. Mann) --- nd
- Folder 6: "Simplicity and Immutability," (W.E. Mann) --- nd
- Folder 7: "Identity and Survival and Related Material" (D. Lewis) --- nd
- Folder 8: "Exposition of the Gospel of John," (St. Thomas Aquinas) --- nd
- Folder 9: "Sketch of a Theory of Language" "Thinking about an Object," (J.L. Pollock) --- nd
- Folder 10: "The Propositional Theory of Language" "Lotteries, Horseraces, Probability and Projection," (J.L. Pollock) --- nd
- Folder 11: "Putnam's Paradox," (D. Lewis) --- nd
- Folder 12: Articles on Evolution --- nd
- Folder 13: "Works and Worlds of Art," (Wolterstorff) --- nd
- Folder 14: "Decisional Learning," (N. Wolterstorff) --- nd
- Folder 15: Wolterstorff's Writings on Ontology --- nd
- Folder 16: "Meaning and Being in Art," (N. Wolterstorff) --- nd
- Box 30
- Folder 1: Propositional Attitudes, (Diana Akerman) --- nd
- Folder 2: Diana Ackerman --- nd
- Folder 3: H. Pietersma --- nd
- Folder 4: B.C. Van Fraassen --- nd
- Folder 5: Richard Foley --- nd
- Folder 6: T.P. Flint --- nd
- Folder 7: "Accidental Necessity," (A.J. Freddoso) --- nd
- Folder 8: "Snapshot Ockhamism," (J. Fischer) --- nd
- Folder 9: R.J. Feenstra --- 1977
- Folder 10: R.M. Adams --- nd
- Folder 11: W.P. Alston --- nd
- Folder 12: David Kaplan --- nd
- Box 31
- Folder 1: Kit Fine --- nd
- Folder 2: Thomas Jager --- nd
- Folder 3: R.W. Gale --- nd
- Folder 4: David Kaplan --- nd
- Folder 5: A Theory of Content and Other Essays --- 1990
Browse by Series:
[
Series 1: [General Materials]],
[
Series 2: Correspondence, 1950-2010],
[
Series 3: Writings, 1963-2008, undated],
[
Series 4: Articles],
[
Series 5: Research Material],
[
Series 6: Research Material; A Theory of Content and Other Essays, by Jerry Fodor, 1990, 1972-1981, undated],
[All]